People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Great spot in Marlboro for takeout and delivery. Their dinners are delicious and come with pasta, salad, and bread. Great for catering as well. Big fan of their Buffalo chicken wrap that they press and their pizza by the slice. ”
“ It's hard to find pizza spots that have a typical NY style slice up this way, but this spot is perfect I always get my haircut next door, but this time we decided to stop in for a slice and some pasta for the kids. The slices were HUGE yet nice and crispy, cheesy, and thin! Staff were very accommodating, they made a kid sized portion of pasta with butter and parmesan for the kids and they ate it up. Definitely coming back here more often! ”
“ Fantastic pie. Dough is tasty, well cooked, ingredients are fresh and full of flavor. The star of the show is the sauce, it's killer, top 3 I've ever had. Must have if you're in the area ”
“ Came to visit my brother in NY to help him move his family's sold estate. We got Marlo's for late/lunch. We got bacon pizza brocoli pizza plain pizza 2 dozen wings mind and honey bbq and garlic knots. Everything was delicious and boy do I miss NY pizza since moving away 3 years ago ”
“ I have never written a review because the delivery person was awesome. But I am drawn to do so today. He is THEE BEST DELIVERY MAN IN THE WORLD! The delivery is always prompt, hot and delivered with a smile. Way professional! ”
“ This place the bomb!!! The food there is exquisite, I believe every pizza is made with awesomeness. The workers I know are homedawgs so that’s what’s up and all the other ones are so nice and friendly. The atmosphere is breathtaking hot take incoming but my favorite part of the atmosphere is this painting that says cheese and the tv playing sports . The place is so clean I think they have a cleaner that kills 100% of bacteria this review getting long so in conclusion This place is THE BOMB and overall good so go here ”
“ Literally can not get better food in Marlboro! Marlo is 100/10 Absolutely amazing food and service. Delivery is beyond fast and everyone who works there is incredibly nice and accommodating. We order here atleast 2xs a week! ”
“ Marlo's Pizzeria is a hidden gem in the heart of the city! From the moment you step inside, you're greeted with the aroma of freshly baked dough and savory toppings. The pizzas are out of this world—perfectly crispy crusts topped with the finest ingredients. The staff is friendly and attentive, making sure your dining experience is nothing short of exceptional. Whether you're a traditionalist or an adventurous eater, Marlo's has something for everyone. Don't miss out on the opportunity to indulge in a slice of pizza perfection! ”
Menu
Mozzarella Sticks
US$9.95Medium Pizza
US$13.95Regular Stromboli
US$11.00Family Stromboli
US$19.00Regular Sausage and Pepper Roll
US$11.00
About
Marlo Pizzeria
Welcome to Marlo Pizzeria, a culinary gem nestled at 1447 Rte 9W, Marlboro, NY 12542. If you’re on the hunt for authentic New York-style pizza, look no further. Marlo Pizzeria brings a slice of the Big Apple right to the heart of Marlboro.
This inviting establishment has gained a reputation for serving up dishes that are not just meals but heartfelt experiences. Their pizza by the slice is legendary; customers rave about the huge, crispy slices loaded with cheese and flavor. It’s a perfect choice for a quick grab after a haircut next door or a family outing. The dough is a standout, showcasing a mastery of pizza-making that’s rarely found outside of New York City.
Alongside their stellar pizza, Marlo offers a delightful assortment of seafood dishes that catch the eye: from a Seafood Combo featuring clams, mussels, shrimp, and scallops in a delightful sauce, to Mussels Marinara and Calamari Fra Diavolo. Each dish is crafted with fresh ingredients, reflecting a commitment to flavor and quality. Customers cannot help but be taken in by the savory richness of their sauces, described as some of the best in the area.
For those looking to cater their events, Marlo's extensive catering menu boasts crowd-pleasers like Full Tray Lasagna, Baked Ziti, and Chicken Marsala. It’s an ideal choice for gatherings, ensuring that everyone leaves the table satisfied.
- Customer Favorites:
- Buffalo Chicken Wrap - a must-try!
- Gigantic, cheesy NY-style pizza slices
- Crispy garlic knots - perfect for sharing
- Customer Feedback:
- "Fantastic pie! The sauce is killer!" - Joshua Denman
- "Great for takeout, big fan of the pizza by the slice!" - Erica Leo
- "The delivery is always prompt, hot, and delivered with a smile!" - Willy Peanut
Marlo Pizzeria does not only thrive on flavor but also on excellent service, making every visit memorable. Whether you’re here for a casual meal or planning a big event, this pizzeria strikes the perfect balance between comfort food and culinary delight. Come for the pizza; stay for the experience! Don’t miss out – give them a ring at +1 845-236-1500 to place your order today!
Book a table